Margarita Island Mexican Kitchen & Bar UNCLAIMED

POPULAR
Margarita Island Mexican Kitchen & Bar, Flagler Beach

Margarita Island Mexican Kitchen & Bar

422 Beach Village Dr, Flagler Beach, FL 32136

Avg. Rating

4.87 out of 5
Service
4.82 out of 5
Atmosphere
Rating: 96% - 19 Reviews

Total

4.79
4.79 out of 5

  Rate & Review Margarita Island 

Margarita Island Details

  • Phone: (386) 338-3435
  • Address:

    422 Beach Village Dr, Flagler Beach, FL 32136

  • Hours:

    Mon-Sat: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Sun: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

  • Price Range: $$$
  • Payment: Accepts credit cards
  • Alcohol Served: Full Liquor Bar
  • Vegan/Vegetarian Options
  •   Margarita Island Menu

 The food and service were good, and the atmosphere and decor were good. The margaritas are not soo good. They were way too sweet and tasted like they... read more!

Review of Margarita Island by Joseph from Palm Coast

Restaurants Nearby to Margarita Island in Flagler Beach

Reviews of Margarita Island Mexican Kitchen & Bar

Add Your Own Review of Margarita Island
  1. Review by Tinsley, Palm Coast 2/6/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The new look is much nicer and more relaxing than the previous Dahlias. Our server was terrific and took good care of us throughout. The food is beautifully presented and tasted really good. It is still very Americanized Mexican food but not as dumbed down as most places with some good flavors. The margarita was probably the highlight of my meal and was very strong. Overall Margarita Island delivered and I was very satisfied with everything here.

    Highlight of visit: The Island Nachos appetizer are a meal on its own, and the Molcajete was a superb feast.

        Tinsley recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Sunning Turtle, Flagler Beach 2/2/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I ordered the ceviche and was disappointed. The presentation was gorgeous. The only fish were whole shrimp that were tough as shoe leather. The room was very noisy even though the restaurant wasn't full.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Pat, Palm Coast 1/31/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Sat at the bar for lunch and had really good service. The food here is really delicious, and the large margarita was a challenge to finish lol 🍹 definitely recommend this new place!

    Highlight of visit: The Carne Asada Fries are awesome and love the San Diego Burrito

        Pat recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Amy, Palm Coast 1/14/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    So happy to have Margarita Island, the best Mexican food in Flagler County. The Goat cheese stuffed peppers are amazing. Have loved everything we have tried. The new design is beat and our server, Madison, was great. Can’t wait to try more dishes. Love!!!

    Highlight of visit: Loved our food, try the goat cheese stuffed peppers. Madison was an excellent server.

        Amy recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Shelley Nedeau, Bunnell 1/13/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Love the new place. Brook Anders is one of the best bartenders in Flagler county. We go there just to see her. The food is delicious. Definitely a high recommendation. You have to go and see for yourself.

    Highlight of visit: Queso dip with s amazing and the flantas. I’m a Tito’s girl and love the way she makes them. So good.

        Shelley Nedeau recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Cindy H., Palm Coast 1/12/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The food and atmosphere are fantastic. In addition, the bartender, Brooke, makes you feel very welcomed with her big smile and warm personality! She is definitely the heart of this restaurant! I suggest you sit at the bar and grab a drink before being seated. I definitely recommend having a drink and dinner at Margarita Island!

        Cindy H. recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Beth, Palm Coast 1/11/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The first time we went to Margarita Island, shortly after they opened, was because one of our favorite bartenders, Brooke, is working there. The redecoration is very very nice. More relaxing atmosphere. Bar stools are much more comfortable! Food was excellent. Brooke was very attentive as always, helping us make adjustments to our orders since all four of us are on Keto diet!! She also makes great 'Skinny Margaritas!'

    Highlight of visit: The Fajita Taco salad is very good, great size for lunch. Lunch fajitas were more than enough food and very good also, even with no beans, no rice or tortillas (keto diet) !!!

        Beth recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Anna Sparks, Flagler Beach 1/9/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Impressed with the food and selection, margaritas, food, and wonderful dessert. Waitresses/Bartender Melanie thank you for a great lunch.

        Anna Sparks recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Ralph Rivero, Palm Coast 1/1/2023
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Went with group of 10 friends on New Year’s Eve and service and food was outstanding. All our meals came out together, servers were very attentive to our needs, food was excellent, and price was good.

    Highlight of visit: All meals were enjoyed by all. Great food, great service and good value.

        Ralph Rivero recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Erica, Flagler 12/27/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Today me and the family went out to this New Mexican restaurant in town that we heard great words around town. Great experience... our server, Melanin was outstanding. Made us feel at home and was super outgoing and attentive even though she was very busy she did a great job. The food came out fast and was very flavorful and fresh. This is definitely our family's new spot. Try them out guys.

    Highlight of visit: Diabla shrimp

        Erica recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Gabriel, Palm Coast 12/26/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I don't usually like to visit restaurants when they first open as I like to wait until they have everything figured out and running smoothly, but we ended up here and I have to say you wouldn't know it was newly open as the staff acted like they had worked there for years and the food was awesome with no hiccups. We thought their flavors were spot on, the meats were tender, and the ingredients were fresh. The remodeling job has much improved the restaurant and we wish them much success.

        Gabriel recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Joseph, Palm Coast 12/21/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The food and service were good, and the atmosphere and decor were good. The margaritas are not soo good. They were way too sweet and tasted like they were made with the bar mix you buy anywhere. I expected fresh sours and top shelf liquor and triple sec for the price. The food really was tasty though.

        Joseph recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Amy Rodgers, Palm Coast 12/17/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The food was delicious. The new update looks beautiful and we had a great service. Can’t wait to eat there again!

        Amy Rodgers recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Jay, Palm Coast 12/17/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Food was very good with nice size portions. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The remodel when transitioning from the previous restaurant gives the dining room a more spacious appearance.

    Highlight of visit: Edwin was very helpful and attentive.

        Jay recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Silas, Palm Coast 12/14/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We had the pleasure of trying this new restaurant today and we were very pleased with the quality of the food, the attentive service, and we thought the new decor was a perfect fit for Flagler. It has a sophisticated beach type of feel with a varied menu and a range of creative margaritas. The appetizer list is quite small and you won't find all the lunch or dinner combos like at other Mexican restaurants, but they do offer you the opportunity to create your own. We thought we'd try one of their chef specialties and I had the Mar y Tierra which is basically a surf and turf steak and shrimp with a queso and cilantro sauce. The seasonings were very good and had a lot more flavor than I expected. My partner selected the Chipotle Salmon which had a cilantro aioli glaze and she said it tasted very good but the char grilled salmon was a little dry. The margaritas were OK but too sweet for us and priced high. We did enjoy it here and will definitely come back to try their more traditional favorites.

        Silas recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Dee, Flagler County 12/12/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We were there today and absolutely enjoyed the great atmosphere with the light background music. The food was delicious. Hubby and I are picky about the spices and herbs that restaurants use and the chef 👩🏻‍🍳🧑🏻‍🍳 cooking technique is awesome in how much spices and herbs are to be used as well as how the food is properly set on the plate in displaying so much quality and color. Large food portions served. We brought leftovers home. We met one of the owner’s and he was so sincere and we hope that they both are blessed in having Margarita Island become successful. Our waitress was totally 💯. She was very attentive to our orders as well as the table behind us. She would swing by to check on us. The owner as well was asking the customers about the food that they had ordered. If they were pleased. Also, we were asked multiple times if we needed anything else. The staff had a smile. We surely will return. The bar area was packed when we left.

        Dee recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Joy Kennedy, Palm Coast 12/11/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Great great great food, the bacon wrapped jalapeño stuffed with goat cheese are outrageously delicious! Everything we ate and drank we really enjoyed. Can’t wait to go back!

    Highlight of visit: Jalapeño stuffed with goat, cheese, wrapped in bacon and the Beria tacos were excellent!

        Joy Kennedy recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Summer, Flagler Beach 12/11/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Much better than Dahlia was in this location and leaps and bounds above Cinco de Mayo. The second day opened and we arrived early but it was already starting to get busy. Loved the new decor and vibe, especially the lighting and the bar area is amazing with a kind of tiki theme. Big choice of margaritas and a few cocktails, and I will say I like how they offer margaritas in different sizes and a pitcher, but they are on the pricey side. The food was delicious! The Bacon & Goat Cheese Jalapenos appetizer was unique and awesome, and the Carnitas were superb. When we left the bar was really buzzing so hope that they keep up with the quality and good service.

        Summer recommends Margarita Island
        
  1. Review by Leilani, Palm Coast 12/10/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Went for opening night and was very impressed!! They have done a really nice job transforming the old Dahlias with its dull gray walls into a more tropical Cancun type of feel. Our server acted like it he's been working there a long time and our food came out in a reasonable amount of time. It seems to be quite a typical menu but the flavors are much better and different and they have their own twist on the classic dishes. They also did some nice plating. I wish them all the best of success. I know the opening night is very high pressure, and I'm sure they'll do very well here.

    Highlight of visit: The Surf & Turf Burrito and Verde Enchiladas were both very tasty. Many other choices and can't wait to try more.

        Leilani recommends Margarita Island