Anthony's Pizza & Pasta UNCLAIMED
Avg. Rating
Food
Anthony's Pizza Details
- Cuisines: Pizza, Pasta, Italian
- Phone: (386) 597-2600
- Address:
250 Palm Coast Pkwy NE, Suite 405, Palm Coast, FL 32137
- Hours:
Mon-Sun: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
- Price Range: $$$
- Payment: Accepts credit cards
- Alcohol Served: Beer/Wine
- Vegan/Vegetarian Options
- Anthony's Pizza Menu
Overview of Anthony's Pizza
Reviews of Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
-
Review by Ariana, Palm Coast 7/31/20234.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
The staff here was pretty young but friendly and quick. The Fried Zucchini was tasty especially the horseradish dipping sauce. My Veggie Calzone was good, just the right amount of filling. My partner enjoyed his Penne with sausage. The place has a nice decor and a casual vibe. Prices were fair for what we got. I recommend Anthony's! 👍🍕🍝
-
Review by Gary, Palm Coast 6/28/20234.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
Nice pizzeria that is reminiscent of the ones we had back in NY with very friendly staff and a welcoming family type atmosphere. Big slices of pizza and good pasta dishes. The Chicken Sorrentino was tasty.
-
Review by Dave, Palm Coast 3/28/20233.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
I often grab a slice or two for lunch and it's always good, so took my family there this weekend and it wasn't so great. One of the pizzas was undercooked and the other was missing toppings. Server wasn't very quick to fix. So disappointed!
-
Review by Cesar, Palm Coast 1/23/20234.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
We had ordered pizza elsewhere and they let us down, so thought we'd give Anthony's a try, and very glad we did as the service was excellent and the pizzas and sides were all awesome. The kids really liked their pizza and thought it was better than our usual place. So I guess Anthony's will be our new go to from now on.
Highlight of visit: I recommend the Sausage Bruschetta Pizza and we all love the Fried Zucchini.
-
Review by Nancy J Wirtes, Palm Coast 12/17/20225.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
My taste buds were dancing. I’m sure everything on the menu is delicious and I could not have had a better waitress- she was phenomenal-took care of the entire dining room flawlessly. Rare to see or have experienced such service in this area, esp. since I was dining alone.
Highlight of visit: Decided on the Penne Rustica. The salad that came with it was premium delicioso. & bread with EVOO. Mwah! All perfection. None of the highly rated beachside restaurants can’t compare their food and service to Anthony’s.
-
Review by Paul, Palm Coast 9/5/20225.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
Their pizza and heroes are great! The Eggplant Parmigiana hero is awesome and they make some excellent NY pies... try the Queens pizza! Staff are friendly and energetic. Comfortable place with nice decor.
Highlight of visit: The Eggplant Parmigiana Hero is delicious and haven't had a bad pizza here yet.
-
Review by Valerie, Palm Coast 7/5/20224.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
It's a cute place inside and the staff was all very friendly. A friend and I just split a Bronx Pizza and we loved it. Ordered another to bring home. Nothing too much bother for the server and we were never rushed. This is a wonderful local pizza parlor that I will definitely frequent.
-
Review by Sandy, Palm Coast 4/19/20225.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
The service makes this restaurant special and our pizza was really good as well. Crust and seasonings were just right and the toppings fresh. Also for a large pizza it was very good value. Cozy place with nice decoration inside.
-
Review by Happy Tummy, Palm Coast 3/24/20225.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
We're lucky to have some good pizza places in town with my favorites all being very close together... Anthony's, Fire in the Hole and Pizza Nostra. The Pizza Nostra I only get to go as it's not the best for dining in, but the other two both have great service and nice atmospheres. Went to Anthony's today and had an awesome pizza - The Bronx, and the girls working there are the best. Love the mix of topping on the pizza and crust and sauce is just how I like it. Great job Anthony's!
Highlight of visit: The Bronx Pizza- has Italian sausage, pepper, onions and mushrooms.
-
Review by Ryan, Palm Coast 12/19/20214.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
Been twice and first for pizza which was very good, but yesterday I had the meatballs which were just OK... the sauce was plain and the meatballs were very bready. Good impression when you walk in and our server was nice. Will stick to ordering pizza next time.




.jpg)













.jpg)

Anthony's Pizza in Palm Coast offers New York-style pizza with a flavorful crust and sauces that many find enjoyable. The Italiano and Margherita pizzas receive frequent praise for their tasty sauce and good cheese coverage, though some note the absence of fresh basil and average-quality toppings on customized pies. Calzones and slices from the counter are reliable lunch options, served by friendly and attentive staff. Pasta dishes such as the Penne Rustica have their fans, appreciated for fresh seasoning and balanced textures, but other pasta options may come off as less fresh. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable, making it a decent spot for families and quick meals. While some find the ingredients could be of higher quality and olives lacking flavor, Anthony's remains a reasonably priced choice with consistent service.
Overview generated from customer feedback.