Anthony's Pizza & Pasta UNCLAIMED

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta, Palm Coast

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

250 Palm Coast Pkwy NE, Suite 405, Palm Coast

Avg. Rating

4.70 out of 5
Service
4.03 out of 5
Atmosphere
Rating: 89% - 35 Reviews

Food

4.47
4.47 out of 5

  Rate & Review Anthony's Pizza 

Anthony's Pizza Details

  • Cuisines: Pizza, Pasta, Italian
  • Phone: (386) 597-2600
  • Address:

    250 Palm Coast Pkwy NE, Suite 405, Palm Coast, FL 32137

  • Hours:

    7-Days: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

  • Price Range: $$$
  • Payment: Accepts credit cards
  • Alcohol Served: Beer/Wine 
  • Vegan/Vegetarian Options
  •   Anthony's Pizza Menu

Overview

Anthony's Pizza in Palm Coast offers a casual setting with friendly, attentive service. Known for its New York-style pizza, the Italiano and Sicilian crusts receive consistent praise for good sauce and texture, though some find certain toppings like olives lacking in flavor. While the pizza generally arrives fresh and hot, pasta dishes receive mixed feedback\-some enjoy options like Penne Rustica and baked ziti, but others find pasta less impressive or frozen in texture. The menu also includes well-liked appetizers such as garlic knots and fried zucchini. Prices are moderate, appealing to those seeking a convenient, neighborhood spot with solid pizza options and a relaxed vibe. Some guests note room for improvement in ingredient quality, but the welcoming staff often enhances the experience.

Overview generated from approved reviews.

Reviews of Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

Add Your Own Review of Anthony's Pizza
  1. Review by Finley, Palm Coast 4/4/2026
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Service was great and it has a nice atmosphere, but the food tasted canned and frozen and not freshly made. If their red sauce is not from a jar, they did a great job at making it taste like it is, and the chicken cutlet had that previously frozen texture. However, the pizza was quite good and I'd order that from here again. Just avoid the pasta dishes.

        Finley recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Bob Savino, Palm Coast 3/4/2026
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    NY pizza at its best! When I call for delivery the pie arrives still hot! A well-deserved 5/5 from this ex-New Yorker!

        Bob Savino recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Sly, Palm Coast 2/12/2026
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Great pizza shop! I had some good slices from the counter and staff were very friendly. Nice place to eat lunch before heading back to work.

        Sly recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Terry, Palm Coast 10/27/2025
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Anthony's is one of our favorite spots. Kids love the food here and we always like their pizza and pasta. NY pizza is made right and the prices are good. Great customer service.

        Terry recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Chris, Palm Coast 8/12/2025
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We created our own pie... went with a square Sicilian with just olives. Good sauce with nice crust but olives cheap with no flavor. Staff were friendly. Not the best pizza in Palm Coast but it's good if you're hungry in this part of town.

        Chris recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Henry, Palm Coast 7/16/2025
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Sat in for lunch and had a couple of slices that were good. Although they were in the case, they tasted fresh and the crust had a good bite. Service was friendly and prices are decent.

        Henry recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Andy, Palm Coast 5/17/2025
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    You can get better pizza in Palm Coast but Anthony’s is pretty good plus it is near my house so I walk there sometimes. The ingredients could be better quality though. Staff are good and the place has a nice casual vibe.

        Andy recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Sam, Palm Coast 3/27/2025
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Loved their pizza! The Italiano was right on he mark. Great crust and sauce. Young lady serving was very good and the decor is nice.

        Sam recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Adam, Palm Coast 11/25/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Nice neighborhood pizza joint. Our pie was decent. Had the Italiano and it tasted good. Definitely a step up over franchise pizza. The youngster serving was very nice. Atmopshere relaxing.

        Adam recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Diana, Palm Coast 10/14/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I'm not a fan of pizza which the rest of my family had and appeared to enjoy, I had the Penne Rustica which was delicious... very garlicky with a buttery wine sauce and penne cooked just with the right amount of 'bite'. Soup was good too and we all liked the Garlic Knots appetizer. Our server was energetic and we were happy to discover Anothony's.

        Diana recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Graham, Palm Coast 8/12/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Found the veggie calzone to be very good and liked the fried zucchini app. Our server was great and the place is clean and relaxing.

        Graham recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Jeff, Palm Coast 8/8/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Damaris is a fantastic server which made our experience even better. The food was fabulous also. Mussels, pizza, baked ziti, calzone and garlic knots.

        Jeff recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Brez, Palm Coast 7/26/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The antipasti salad and Stromboli were very good. My son had pizza that he liked. Young lady serving was very pleasant and they have a comfortable atmosphere.

        Brez recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Bong, Palm Coast 5/10/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I’d say that the pizza at Anthony’s is above average… often grab some slices for lunch whichever ones look freshly made. Staff are good but occasionally get one that doesn’t seem happy to be there.

        Bong recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Andrew, Palm Coast 1/6/2024
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Good quality pizza very close to NY style and some good entrees. Bruschetta appetizer tasted good but was a bit messy and hard to eat. Service is very friendly.

        Andrew recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by F seecrist, Palm Coast 12/18/2023
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Excellent pizza. The sauce the perfect blend that takes you back to NYC and Philly. Fantastic server I had. Polite fast n sweet.

    Highlight of visit: Pizza

        F seecrist recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by River, Palm Coast 10/14/2023
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Had a couple of slices and although not the best pizza I've had, it was still quite good and my son liked his Meatball Hero. Server was friendly but needed to refill drinks more.

        River recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by George, Palm Coast 9/19/2023
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Very pleased with our pie... good NY style with all the right ratios. One of the best I've had locally. Server very friendly but not very attentive... had to keep asking for everything like refills. Typical pizzeria atmosphere but clean and comfortable.

        George recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Ariana, Palm Coast 7/31/2023
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The staff here was pretty young but friendly and quick. The Fried Zucchini was tasty especially the horseradish dipping sauce. My Veggie Calzone was good, just the right amount of filling. My partner enjoyed his Penne with sausage. The place has a nice decor and a casual vibe. Prices were fair for what we got. I recommend Anthony's! ðŸ‘ðŸ•ðŸ

        Ariana recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Gary, Palm Coast 6/28/2023
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Nice pizzeria that is reminiscent of the ones we had back in NY with very friendly staff and a welcoming family type atmosphere. Big slices of pizza and good pasta dishes. The Chicken Sorrentino was tasty.

        Gary recommends Anthony's Pizza