Anthony's Pizza & Pasta UNCLAIMED

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta, Palm Coast

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

250 Palm Coast Pkwy NE, Suite 405, Palm Coast, FL 32137

Avg. Rating

4.44 out of 5
Service
4.17 out of 5
Atmosphere
Rating: 85% - 18 Reviews

Total

4.25
4.25 out of 5

  Rate & Review Anthony's Pizza 

Anthony's Pizza Details

  • Cuisines: Pizza, Pasta, Italian
  • Phone: (386) 597-2600
  • Address:

    250 Palm Coast Pkwy NE, Suite 405, Palm Coast, FL 32137

  • Price Range: $$$
  • Payment: Accepts credit cards
  • Alcohol Served: No
  •   Anthony's Pizza Menu

 Got my haircut next door so decided to have dinner after. Cute inside with a fun mural and brick accents, but it did have a feeling of needing to be cleaned...... read more!

Review of Anthony's Pizza by Jacob from Palm Coast

Restaurants Nearby to Anthony's Pizza in Palm Coast

Reviews of Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

Add Your Own Review of Anthony's Pizza
  1. Review by Paul, Palm Coast 9/5/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Their pizza and heroes are great! The Eggplant Parmigiana hero is awesome and they make some excellent NY pies... try the Queens pizza! Staff are friendly and energetic. Comfortable place with nice decor.

    Highlight of visit: The Eggplant Parmigiana Hero is delicious and haven't had a bad pizza here yet.

        Paul recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Arlo, Palm Coast 7/17/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    This is excellent NY style pizza with really good workers and a nice atmosphere. The Queens pizza is my usual choice plus their pasta dishes and stromboli are very good too.

        Arlo recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Valerie, Palm Coast 7/5/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    It's a cute place inside and the staff was all very friendly. A friend and I just split a Bronx Pizza and we loved it. Ordered another to bring home. Nothing too much bother for the server and we were never rushed. This is a wonderful local pizza parlor that I will definitely frequent.

        Valerie recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Sandy, Palm Coast 4/19/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    The service makes this restaurant special and our pizza was really good as well. Crust and seasonings were just right and the toppings fresh. Also for a large pizza it was very good value. Cozy place with nice decoration inside.

        Sandy recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Happy Tummy, Palm Coast 3/24/2022
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We're lucky to have some good pizza places in town with my favorites all being very close together... Anthony's, Fire in the Hole and Pizza Nostra. The Pizza Nostra I only get to go as it's not the best for dining in, but the other two both have great service and nice atmospheres. Went to Anthony's today and had an awesome pizza - The Bronx, and the girls working there are the best. Love the mix of topping on the pizza and crust and sauce is just how I like it. Great job Anthony's!

    Highlight of visit: The Bronx Pizza- has Italian sausage, pepper, onions and mushrooms.

        Happy Tummy recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Ryan, Palm Coast 12/19/2021
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Been twice and first for pizza which was very good, but yesterday I had the meatballs which were just OK... the sauce was plain and the meatballs were very bready. Good impression when you walk in and our server was nice. Will stick to ordering pizza next time.

        Ryan recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Orlando, Palm Coast 11/23/2021
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    First impressions were good as we were greeted by friendly staff and a clean and cozy atmosphere. The pizza was very good and had a great crust and nice flavor. Ordered a Penne Genovese to go for next day and that was delicious! A good experience and nice local restaurant for a good meal.

    Highlight of visit: The Penne Genovese was really tasty and would order that again.

        Orlando recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Paul, Palm Coast 10/20/2021
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Their pie is really good. Order often and like the crust and right amount of cheese and sauce with good seasonings. Pasta dishes are same old so always stick with pizza.

        Paul recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Steve, Palm Coast 5/8/2021
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I've tried so many pizzas in Palm Coast and this is my favorite so far. I like the atmosphere and service and reminds of one of my favorite places from back in Philly. Only dined in so can't comment on their takeout or delivery services but highly recommend you try for eating inside.

        Steve recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Drew, Palm Coast 8/10/2020
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Nice little local neighborhood joint with friendly service and decent food. Pies are good and they make pretty tasty sauces. Prices on some dishes a little high. Atmosphere is welcoming with faux brick decor and Italian street scene murals.

        Drew recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by George S., Palm Coast 3/15/2020
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We enjoy visiting here and have done so on several occasions and have always had very good meals. We usually get pizza and occasionally a pasta dish everything has been delicious and well presented. However, we recently ordered delivery for the first time and it was like the service and food came from a different restaurant. Not sure what went wrong but the pizza was sloppy and a mess and even ordering on the phone was an ordeal! Hoping this was a one off as we do like Anthony's and like to support independent businesses, especially in critical times like these.

        George S. recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Jonathan, Palm Coast 12/11/2019
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Just another pizza and pasta joint but the atmosphere is really nice and staff welcoming. Pizza is very good and their sauces make their pasta dishes tasty. But Philly Cheesesteak was a let down and don't recommend. Garlic knots are awesome! Worth visiting!

    Highlight of visit: Eggplant Caprese Pizza

        Jonathan recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Alexa, Palm Coast 7/19/2019
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Nice and clean casual restaurant with good pizza and pasta and Italian dishes. The Pesto Bruschetta and Sausage Pizza is our favorite. Eggplant Lasagna very tasty too. Service is friendly and they always remember us. We visit often and highly recommend it.

    Highlight of visit: Pesto Bruschetta Sausage Pizza

        Alexa recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Johnny, Palm Coast 6/5/2019
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Impressive! Pizza was good with good sauce ratio and the eggplant parm was awesome and the best I've had for a very long time. It's quite small and located in a shopping center but very nice atmosphere and decorations. Our server was very good and prices reasonable, especially the beer and wine prices. We'll be regulars for sure.

    Highlight of visit: Eggplant Parm - The Best!

        Johnny recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Jacob, Palm Coast 4/2/2019
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Got my haircut next door so decided to have dinner after. Cute inside with a fun mural and brick accents, but it did have a feeling of needing to be cleaned... it wasn't really dirty but just grimy. I had a Veggie Calzone which I thought was expensive at nearly $14! It tasted OK but didn't have much flavor at all and I have certainly had much better elsewhere. Server was friendly enough but didn't seem to care too much beyond making sure I got my food and check. No real reasons to return here - just average. At least I tried.

        Jacob recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Paul, Palm Coast 1/18/2019
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    There was a time, a long time ago, when they first opened, when their pizza was pretty darned good. But, after a while they've become very complacent and the quality of their products has been compromised. The service was always horrible but the pizza was good so you tolerate the lousy, downright horrendous service. When both the pizza AND the service become awful then it's time to move on.

        Paul recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Christen, Palm Coast 12/7/2018
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Ordered dinner for delivery online, food was there before expected and it was delicious! Couldn’t ask for more.

        Christen recommends Anthony's Pizza
        
  1. Review by Patm, Palm Coast 10/5/2018
    Overall: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Ordered a medium pizza to take home. Requested thin, crisp crust, and selected toppings. The pizza was great. Crust was perfect, and plenty of the selected toppings. Best pizza we have had in a long time.

        Patm recommends Anthony's Pizza