Tony's Pizza CLAIMED
Tony's Pizza Details
- Cuisines: Pizza
- Phone: (386) 439-9900
- Address:
428 Beach Village Drive, Flagler Beach, FL 32136
- Hours:
Seven Days a Week
11am-9pm - Price Range: $$
- Payment: Accepts credit cards
- Alcohol Served: Beer/Wine
- Vegan/Vegetarian Options
- Tony's Pizza Menu
Overview of Tony's Pizza
Reviews of Tony's Pizza
-
Review by Alyssa, Flagler Beach 5/11/20265.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
We come to Tony's for their vegan pizza which uses all plant based products, including the cheese, and with their tomato sauce, it tastes amazing. None of that awful cardboard taste you get in other pizza places. I'm just grateful they offer options for us vegans as it's hard around Flagler to try and eat kindly.
-
Review by Daniel, Fort Myers FLA 12/18/20255.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
In town for a few days staying at an Airbnb for work, and Tony's has been my go-to for dinner when heading back to the house. Their pies are awesome and I had a great stromboli. Staff are upbeat and service is fast.
-
Review by Jack Benson, Palm Coast 11/18/20255.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
HUGE slices of cheese and friendly staff. Worth the drive from Palm Coast (I pass by many pizzerias to get to Tony's). Over the years the inside has evolved eloquently. Paulie (not Tony) bought the pizzeria at 19 years old and has really changed up the original vibe without changing or compromising the product, cool to see over the years. Always rooting for Paulie and Tony's Pizza!
Highlight of visit: The new Grandma style slices are a MUST TRY!
-
Review by Mike, Palm Coast 11/13/20255.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
Tony's has the BEST pizza. I usally get the Veggie Delight and it tastes fresh and is loaded with toppings. I know everyone has their favorite pizza spot and tells you there's is just like back in NJ or NY, but I'm from Hammonton NJ and Tony's tastes just like the local spot I grew up eating pizza from. So it's a taste of home for me.
-
Review by Annie, Flagler Beach 7/19/20252.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
The lady serving was very friendly and the restaurant is clean and fun decorated, but the pizza was a letdown. Just didn't have much flavor and the crust was tough. Very plastic like cheese and ingredients tasted like canned. You can find much better pizza close by.
-
Review by Taylor, Palm Coast 5/20/20235.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
We come here as it's one of the very few local restaurants that has good vegan options. The Balsamic Mushroom and the Happy Vegan pizzas are our favorites but everything has been delicious including the Bruschetta. The staff is friendly and will guide you through the menu and what can be veganized.
Highlight of visit: The vegan Balsamic Mushroom Pizza is my fav 🍕đź‹
-
Review by Chris, Palm Coast 10/20/20223.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
One of those strip mall pizza places with no personality. It's clean and nice enough inside, but there is no soul here! No Tony (Paulie) is welcoming you just a couple of women who although they did a good job, looked and acted like they had a little part in the restaurant and said the owner just appears occasionally to collect the money. We ordered some slices that were ok but doubt we'd return as there are many other far better choices for pizzerias around Flagler to choose from. It's a shame that the restaurant doesn't live up to the story.
-
Review by Andrew, Ohio 8/9/20225.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
Probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Ordered the large Margherita pizza and even though I had to wait 2 hours for it to be delivered it was worth every penny and every second waited. Hope to be back in Florida sometime and will definitely order it again.
-
Review by Robert, Flagler Beach 6/19/20213.5.0Food:Service:Atmosphere:
We moved here a few months ago and been searching for the prefect pizza, and as much as we quite liked Tony's it's not our perfect pizza. The pie was above average and exceeded franchise pizzas but needed more flavor and we thought ingredients tasted frozen or canned. Service wasn't the best either and think our server was having a bad day. usual strip mall vibe inside with cliched picture and posters on the wall. Yawn! Recommend for an OK pizza that at least beats Doms or the Hut.









.jpg)










Tony's Pizza in Flagler Beach serves New York-style hand-tossed pies with generous toppings and flavorful tomato sauce. Vegan diners appreciate the plant-based options like the Happy Vegan and Balsamic Mushroom pizzas, which avoid the usual cardboard taste found elsewhere. The Veggie Delight and Margherita are favorites among regulars who value fresh ingredients and a taste reminiscent of hometown spots in New Jersey. Service tends to be friendly and attentive, though occasional lapses have been noted. The restaurant's atmosphere features typical Italian-themed decor in a clean, casual setting. While some find the crust and cheese occasionally lacking in flavor or texture, many choose Tony's for its consistent quality and careful delivery practices, especially appreciated during times requiring contactless service. Prices remain affordable for the portion sizes and quality offered.
Overview generated from customer feedback.