Giuseppe's NY Pizza & Italian Restaurant PERMANENTLY CLOSED

CLOSED
Giuseppe's NY Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Flagler Beach

Giuseppe's NY Pizza & Italian Restaurant

301 Moody Blvd., Flagler Beach, FL 32136

Avg. Rating

out of 5
Service
out of 5
Atmosphere
Rating: 74% - 38 Reviews

Food

3.71
3.71 out of 5

Giuseppe's Details (Closed)

  • Cuisines: Pizza, Pasta, Italian
  • Phone: (386) 439-5404
  • Address:

    301 Moody Blvd., Flagler Beach, FL 32136

  • Hours: Closed
  • Price Range: $$$
  • Payment: All Major Credit Cards
  • Alcohol Served: Beer/Wine 

Restaurants Nearby to Giuseppe's in Flagler Beach

Reviews of Giuseppe's NY Pizza & Italian Restaurant

PERMANENTLY CLOSED
  1. Review by Philippa Hope, Palm Bay 8/5/2015
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I will never order food any where else. At Giuseppe's you get what you ask for and a lot more. Especially when they deliver to your hotel room. I was impressed at the service over the phone, delivery person, price, and food. I didn't get my parmesan cheese but to be honest I didn't care. They bought me paper plates, cups for my 2 liter, extra napkins, & utensils. We will never order any where else. They have a lot of menu items to choose from so I will get something different ever time my boyfriend works at the Sea Ray plant. Being 3 hours away from Giuseppe's made me feel at home. Thank you Giuseppe's.

        Philippa Hope recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Ed T, Flagler Beach 9/3/2014
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Been in town a week now and ordered my pizza 5 minutes before closing and Jamie was happy to help me. The pie was awesome with a crisp crust and ready on time. I am a believer in honest reviews and I will return for sure.

        Ed T recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by David Palm, Flagler Beach 7/20/2014
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I am fairly new to the Flagler Beach area so have been trying most of the various local restaurants and beach bars. I was looking for a good take-out place for sub sandwiches and decided to try Guuseppe's as they have takeout as well as table service. When I went to the counter to order an Italian sub, the server did not know what that was so the owner had to explain it to her. They made me one as I ordered and when I ate it at home, it was the blandest thing I ever tasted. I don't know what brand of meat or cheese they use but it was not good. And it cost close to $10!

    I decided to try their pizza a little later since they must be in business for some good reason. The pizza was just about as bad as the sub. Maybe sitting down inside and getting an Italian meal might be better but I'll never know because I'll never be back.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Russ Pendred, Ocean Isle Beach, NC 10/8/2013
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I stop at Guuseppe's every time we drive down to Florida from NC. I think their meals are very fairly priced for the quality and quantity they provide. The atmosphere is friendly. I have NEVER had a problem with quality or service - they will always do what is right to please the customer. We go to Italy at least once every two years and I think Giuseppe's is as good as you will find in Rome - their sauce is a little spicy but fantastic.

        Russ Pendred recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Dimitri G., Henrico, VA 8/30/2013
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Giuseppe's was once a very busy, good place. All of a sudden, I come again, and I ordered Calamari with some sauce, not sure what it's called, and with spaghetti. It was a spicy sauce, but it was way too much sauce put on the dish, I had asked for sauce on the side, it was all over my dish, and the sauce was way too spicy. Because my stomach hurt, I tried a slice of pizza, which was okay, I've had much better pizza before. By then, I literally lost my appetite. We told our waitress I wasn't satisfied, my meal was not on the house. To wrap it up, watch what you order, and I would not recommend this place.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by L, Flagler County 8/18/2013
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    This place has really gone down hill. My husband and I went for dinner, ordered pizza and added salad bar to our meal. Salad bar was not great, lettuce was going bad and not many toppings to choose from. Soup on the salad bar was awful, noodles in the soup were soggy, like it had been reheated many times. We didn't realize the salad didn't look good because there was hardly any lighting, like they were trying to hide it. Then we got the bill and each salad bar was $9!!! Menu said $2.99 to add to meal but we didn't realize it didn't include if we had pizza. We asked the waitress and she said "oh ya, I guess I should've mentioned that"! Uh, ya $9 for basically a side salad! We asked her to talk to her manager about it and thankfully they did adjust it to the $2.99. The pizza was just OK. The restaurant needs attention and some TLC. I will not go back.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by rogena, marzuolo 3/28/2013
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We expected it to be much better. We waited about an hour for our cold pizza, the servers were not very attentive; we had to keep getting their attention to get service and the dirty dishes never left our table until we mentioned it ourselves. The servers were nice enough they just seemed kind of confused. Nice atmosphere, I don't know, maybe it was just some bad timing on our part to have gone in when we did- we might go try a second time in the future, but it is more likely that we will not.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Rudy, Daytona Beach 10/11/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We drive from Daytona to Flagler for the Pizza. It is the best Pizza we have ever eaten. To that man that commented of a high price for Pizza, Ya get what ya pay for, take your $10.00 and go to Papa Johns or somewhere. You can't compare. I'll pay a couple dollars more for a superb Pizza. Keep up the good work Jenny. You are awesome. We will keep coming back.

        Rudy recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Sarah, Flager Beach 8/13/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I think for all the Italian restaurants in Flagler County, they would be a little more competitive with their pricing. VERY expensive! We ordered 2 LG pizzas and it was over $40.00. That's just crazy to me. Needs to do some serious cleaning and get rid of all the tacky Italian decor, just cause I'm in a pizzeria doesn't mean I want to see Godfather posters hanging everywhere. My next Italian visit will be to Joseph's or Rockys.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Aniello Gallo, Palm Coast 6/15/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Giueseppe's quantifies what rudimentary Italian cuisine should not be - noodles with some sauce!! I also heard people rave about the place, only to be disappointed by the menu, the watery sauce, and the store bought pasta that they overcharge for dinner. The server seemed to be too preoccupied talking with her friends, and from what I could see of the kitchen it looked sloppy. Very poor quality.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Michael S, Palm Coast 3/24/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Had high hopes after reading some of the reviews here, but not sure what all the fuss is about. Very ordinary Italian food with a nondescript sauce. It isn't that Giuseppi's is bad, but it just isn't "5-star" special and there are plenty of other better Italian places in Flagler County.

        Not recommended
        
  1. Review by Fred CIgliano, Flagler Beach, Fl 3/22/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I'm from Brooklyn, New York and not fa nothing, I know good Pizza and Calzone when I eat it. Joe knows just what his customers want and is especially good when it comes to service and price... Samantha and the other servers are the best there is no other place i would rather eat than at Giuseppe's. Sorry but all the other places on 100 and south /and north don't come close... sorry Rocco and Joe's.

        Fred CIgliano recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Miss Peach, Georgia 3/19/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    This was my fourth visit, this time on a Sunday. Every other time we've had superior service, but this time the service was terrible. I asked our server for silverware and bread plates and waited so long that I got up and got them myself. On the plus side, the food, as always, was excellent. Our table had the spanokopita, spaghetti with meat sauce, fettucine carbonara, and all of it was excellent. In spite of the poor service (lack of training and/or poor scheduling with only one wait person?) I would come back again when I'm in Flagler.

        Miss Peach recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Jack, Palm Coast 3/11/2012
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I'm not too sure what constitutes as gourmet pizza but I think that may be a bit of a stretch for this place. However, the pizza was good. It's NY style which I prefer and I really liked the Mediterranean. They also sell the usual stromboli's, calzones and subs. They also have a lunch buffet they claim is very good which I'll try one day. Service is good and the restaurant is comfortable and basic.

        Jack recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Vickie, Virginia 9/19/2011
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    We visited Giuseppe's on Friday September 16th, I had read reviews and wanted to try it, we got the Tour of Italy, Lobster Ravioli, Stromboli and a Veal dish that I can't remember what it was actually called. My sister said the Lobster Ravioli was wonderful, my niece said the stromboli was a stromboli, my nephew had the veal dish and honestly I thought he was going to lick the plate.

    The eggplant parmesan was the best thing on my plate but the lasagna was awful. The sauce that covered everything on the plate was amazing. However, I would not order this dish again. My nephew tasted the the lasagna and said it had an odd taste to it, I'm not sure if the cheese was bad but it was just awful, the other item on the tour of Italy was the same way, it had an odd flavor to it just like the lasagna.

    I will probably try this restaurant again but try a different dish. My Nephew said he would give this restaurant a B+ and he said the lasagna brought it down from a A- to a B+.

        Vickie recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Frank Baker, Palm Coast 9/17/2011
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    I have always had a great meal here! I found it almost two years ago and try to stop in as often as I can. I've had most of the menu and it is always perfect and the best! Nikki is an awesome waitress and always has a smile and remembers a face. With music in the background it is the best to go to for dinner or lunch. Was there on the 4th of July and was able to watch fireworks from my table while having a wonderful dinner!

        Frank Baker recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Mary Ann Reese, Flagler Beach 5/9/2011
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    This is our favorite Italian restaurant in the entire area. Homemade sauce that's slow-cook and seasoned perfectly - generous portions and great service. This place has it all. They offer every Italian entree you might want and we've tried just about all of them and never been disappointed. So much more to offer than just great pizza. Be sure to try it for lunch as well because their buffet is great! If you want good Italian food with that homemade flavor then you owe it to yourself to eat at Guiseppe's.

        Mary Ann Reese recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Tony & MIchaelyn Milidantri, Palm Coast 9/12/2010
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Two week ago, after unsuccessfully trying to get into Mezzaluna (on Belle Terre), the 4 of us decided to try Giuseppe's in Flagler Beach. This was our first visit to this restaurant and we were pleasantly surprised. The restaurant was pretty full and we had to wait a few minutes for a table but the service was fast. Don't recall what each of us ordered; however, we had 4 different entrees and we were not disappointed. Prices were reasonable, we enjoyed our meals and the service was very good. We will definitely return.

        Tony & MIchaelyn Milidantri recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Marcy Kuznik, St. Augustine, FL 7/9/2010
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    My stops at this restaurant have always been at lunch time. Usually my friends and I order a salad and pizza, which is always tasty My last visit the waitress suggested spinach ravioli to me and said they were homemade. Whoever made them, they were delicious! Now, when I get back down to Flagler Beach, it will be for more of those plump little dumplings.

        Marcy Kuznik recommends Giuseppe's
        
  1. Review by Linda, Flagler Beach 6/28/2010
    Food: 
    Service: 
    Atmosphere: 

    Good Italian comfort food served in a friendly atmosphere. Sauces can be a little too sweet for me but flavors are nice.

        Linda recommends Giuseppe's